Debit Card Usage Surpasses Credit Cards in 2006

Appoorva Saxena ,Vice President, Financial Services & Industry Analysis, Callahan & Associates
1/1/2007
Read Count:4962
Avg. from 7 Rating(s) - Comments (1)

According to the 2007 edition of the ATM & Debit News EFT Data Book, people are pulling out their debit cards more often. In 2006, debit card usage surpassed credit card usage for the first time. Cardholders are on mark to conduct 26.6 billion transactions at the point-of-sale this year while credit card transactions are projected to be 24.4 billion.

POS vs ATM

Monthly Pin-Based Transactions
2006
2005
Growth
ATM 842 877 -4.0%
Point-of-Sale 840.2 684.2 22.80%
Total EFT 1,682.3 1,553.2 7.40%
Source: ATM&Debit News EFT Data Book Sept 2006
March data, in Millions, after eliminating duplication from gateway transactions

Debit card usage at point-of-sale locations grew nearly 23% between March 2005 and 2006 while pin-based transactions at ATMs, the traditional primary point-of-use, actually declined 4% during the same period, further emphasizing the trend that consumers are increasingly using debit to pay for their lattes as well as to get cash.

What Does it Mean for Credit Unions?

With debit card usage continuing to rise, members’ choice of their primary financial institution (PFI) becomes more important. Credit unions that are able to secure, and reinforce, this status will realize greater transaction volume and higher interchange income from members who utilize debit cards.

A case-in-point is Wings Financial Federal Credit Union ($1.6 Billion in Apple Valley, Minnesota) that already generates 29% of its non-interest income from debit card interchange due to high debit card usage among its members, compared to 16% from credit cards. Despite this already high number, to solidify its position as the PFI for their members the credit union, with 75% checking account penetration, is rolling out a cash-back debit rewards program for its members in 2007.

“We see debit cards replacing cash and checks” says Timothy Keegan, EVP/CFO for Wings Financial, “and since checking accounts are critical for member relationships, offering debit cards will allow us to serve our members better. We see this as an opportunity to give back.”

In an era of tight margins and slowing member growth, the ability to generate member-friendly non-interest income from sources such as this and maintain existing member relationships’ is critical to credit unions’ business model.

To learn how credit unions are getting their cards in their members’ wallets, join your peers on for our webinar on “Strategies for Driving Debit Card Usage,” brought to you by Callahan & Associates and sponsored by PSCU Financial Services.

Please rate this article
  1 2 3 4 5  
Poor Excellent
  • Add Your Comment
  • Comments
Please rate this article
  1 2 3 4 5  
Poor Excellent


Name:
 (Optional)

Comment:  (Optional)

E-mail:  (Optional, to be notified of new comments)
  Privacy

Comment Guidelines
Comment # 1 (Posted by an unknown user ) Thursday, January 04, 2007
Rating:
Overall very informative article. However, the percentages of non-interest income cited for Wings FCU are skewed by the fact that they incurred a $1.2M loss on sale of investments which lowered their overall non-interest income. Look behind the statistics if they seem unusually high. Industry publications do this regularly. The CU Journal in it's 11/29/06 edition listed the top 10 CUs based on their third quarter ROA's. One of the top 10 sold their credit portfolio during the year, and had an ROA of -.92% in 2005 versus their 3.58% annualized ROA as of 9/30/06. Statistics can be deceiving. Wings FCU does have an impressive penetration of their membership with their checking accounts, and the percentage of their non-interest income (adjusted for the $1.2M loss) is stll pretty good, but nowhere near as impressive as your article conveys.

Advertising
More on Payment Systems
The Overdraft Fee Controversy: Did the Consumer Have the Right Balance in Mind? For all the hoopla in the press, the legislative grandstanding for consumer groups, and the finger pointing at financial institutions about the abuses of overdraft processing services, it still comes down to one simple idea.
Graph of the Week: Total Credit Card Loans Outstanding
CUtv Short: The Right Time to Emphasize Responsible Card Offerings Kevin Marvel, Marketing Director at APL FCU, discusses how the CU has found success through a multi-faceting marketing campaign emphasizing a basic card with very transparent benefits.
Unlocking the Door of Opportunity in Today’s Economic Environment Good times breed routine evaluations for efficiency gains – tough times mandate efficiency improvements as a life-line. What is your credit union doing? Are you looking at technology to improve your back office operations?
CARD Act 2009: Seven Suggestions for Managing this Critical Mandate Another governmentally-imposed tsunami has washed ashore! Legislation rolls in as quickly as ocean waves, drowning its victims under a storm-tossed sea of churning regulations.
more...
Other Articles by Appoorva Saxena
Catch ‘Em Young: Grow Membership and Drive Debit Usage How Oxford FCU is having success with its’ two-pronged strategy that is attracting younger members and driving up debit card usage.
High ROA: Not Just for Big Credit Unions Anymore Is size the key to strong bottom line performance? A closer look at mid-year data provides some answers.
Is a High ROA Available Only to Big Credit Unions? Part II Achieving a higher return on assets is not necessarily dependent on total asset size – as there are similarities in return for both large and smaller players.
BECU Posts 19% Share Growth and Rising Membership in 3rd Quarter Defying the stall in industry growth rates, BECU is growing shares at five times the national average according to First Look data. What is driving their success?
How are the Largest Credit Unions Performing at Mid-Year? Slower share growth, tighter margins and a declining member growth rate are the headline trends industry-wide – Are the largest credit unions experiencing these same trends at mid-year?
19.2% Loan Growth Drives Navy Federal’s Second Quarter Results Growth in loans, members, and employees yield an impressive “First Look” at the nation’s largest credit union’s second quarter data.
Gift Cards: Frequently Asked Questions Thinking about a gift card program for your credit union? Here are some of the key points to consider.
Stored value and Prepaid Cards: Untapped Potential Prepaid cards are gaining in popularity. How big a piece of this $186 billion pie will your credit union get?
Katrina Aftermath: Louisiana CUs Face Rising Delinquencies Six months after the Katrina hurricane – the costliest hurricane in recorded US history – Louisiana’s credit unions are battling a rising tide of delinquencies.
Employment in Credit Unions (Part III): Employee Productivity This is the final article of our series on employment trends and statistics focusing on headcount, salaries & benefits, and productivity in the credit union industry from December 2000 to December 2005.
Articles By Date
 
Most Popular Products
Peer to Peer

The most advanced financial performance software on the market-perfect for CFOs and CEOs who like to get their hands dirty with the numbers!

More Info>

CUAnalyzer

Designed for anyone in the industry, new or veteran, CUAnalyzer uses the powerful engine of our Peer-to-Peer software but provides educational tools to back up the graphing and reporting capabilities.

Login       More Info>

Credit Union Directory
For the first time in 22 years, the 2008 Credit Union Directory is now available in two versions, traditional and a new Briefcase Edition.
Login More Info>
CU Strategy & Performance (CUSP)

Credit Union Strategy and Performance (CUSP) is Callahan's new hybrid print/online quarterly financial analysis publication that will place our expertise in analysis and consulting right in the palm of your hands.

More Info>

Login More Info>
Advertising Advertising