Credit Unions Capture 9% of U.S. Deposits

Sam Brownell ,Industry Analyst, Callahan & Associates, Inc

11/2/2009
Read Count:897
Avg. from 3 Rating(s) -

As of June 2009, credit unions deposit market share reached 8.98%, up six basis points from the same point in 2008. Over the past year, turmoil in the stock market and across the financial services industry helped credit unions add a record amount of shares and pick up additional market share.

Recently released FDIC deposit data shows that credit unions and banks both benefited from market instability as consumers moved to the safety of insured savings. The slight increase in credit union market share is also a sign of more deposits moving to "local" institutions.

Below is the table of the five states in which credit unions grew their market share by the largest percentage. Market share growth in these states has been driven both by the success of credit unions as well as by bank troubles. For example, the collapse of Washington Mutual in September of 2008, which previously held $188.3 billion in deposits nationally, had a significant impact on Washington credit unions' increased market share in the state.

Credit Union Market Share Data as of June 30th, 2009

Source: Branch Analyzer

 

June ‘08 Market Share

June ‘09 Market Share

Change (% pts)

Rhode Island

9.7%

11.0%

1.3%

Texas

9.1%

10.2%

1.2%

Washington

17.4%

18.5%

1.1%

Vermont

15.2%

16.2%

1.0%

Missouri

6.6%

7.3%

0.8%

 

It is also encouraging to see that in some states, where they have a smaller market share, credit unions are making steps towards expanding their reach. For example, New Jersey credit unions held 3.7% of the market as of June ‘08 but have now expanded their share of the states' deposits to 4.1%, an 11.3% improvement over the past year.

Credit Union Market Share Data as of June 30th, 2009

Source: Branch Analyzer

 

 June ‘08 Market Share

June ‘09 Market Share

Change (% of Mkt Share)

Texas

9.1%

10.2%

13.1%

Rhode Island

9.7%

11.0%

12.9%

Mississippi

6.1%

6.8%

12.0%

Missouri

6.6 %

7.3%

11.7%

New Jersey

3.7%

4.1%

11.3%

 

These states provide examples of the gains that credit unions can make from continuing to deliver value to members. While some credit unions have tried to slow deposit growth in order to maintain capital ratios, the data shows that opportunities remain.

With bank failures continuing to make news, opportunities will continue into 2010. According to research conducted by Callahan & Associates, branches that are taken over by new financial institutions typically lose at least 15-20% of their deposits, which means that each of these bank closures provides opportunities for credit unions to attract new members and new relationship in the effected communities.

Callahan & Associates can help you identify and quantify the opportunities resulting from these closures with our analytical tool, Branch Analyzer.

Please rate this article
  1 2 3 4 5  
Poor Excellent
  • Add Your Comment
  • Comments
Please rate this article
  1 2 3 4 5  
Poor Excellent


Name:
 (Optional)

Comment:  (Optional)

E-mail:  (Optional, to be notified of new comments)
  Privacy

Comment Guidelines
Advertising
More on Deposit Strategies
The Cost of Funds Considering notional versus marginal costs is vital for deposit pricing during a period of sustained low interest rates.
Support Local Commerce. Deposit With a Credit Union. Municipal deposits could spur local economic recovery and development.
Think BIG Gesa Credit Union’s Colossal Checking product does more than generate high balances. It attracts account holders who are willing to invest their full financial relationship with the credit union, and its rate-sustaining e-initiatives educate members about electronic services.
Health Savings Accounts and Credit Unions: A Success Story for Today’s Environment Health care reform is heating up in Washington, D.C., and credit unions across the country are joining in the search for effective health care solutions.
Why Teller Capture Trumps Other Capture Solutions The speed at which deposit capture tools have evolved since Check 21 legislation was enacted in 2004 has been dizzying. In five short years, we’ve seen branch capture, merchant capture, ATM capture ... and now teller capture.
more...
Other Articles by Sam Brownell
Gen Y Perspective: Why My PFI is a Credit Union The story behind my decision to move my money from PNC to Lafayette Credit Union and what I believe credit unions can learn from it.
Credit Unions Post Record Loan Originations While Obama has to call Wall Street bankers to Washington to get them to open their credit lines, credit unions are doing it without being told.
Credit Union Loan Volume Continues to Rise in Third Quarter The author of a recent article in the Wall Street Journal discussing J.P. Morgan’s tightening lending practices said “… it will be a long time before the business of making loans recovers.” This may be true for banks, but credit unions have shown that they will continue to make loans to meet their members’ needs.
Strategic Benchmarking: Business Model Based Peer Groups For every characteristic of a credit union’s business model, there is also a data point that should be considered when defining a peer group. Here are three starting points to give you an idea of how you could define your own business model.
The Power of Data: Are You Benchmarking Accurately? As one point of contact for questions regarding Callahan & Associates' financial analysis software, I have firsthand knowledge of how many people in the industry select a "peer group" of credit unions for benchmarking. Almost all of you are doing it wrong.
As Banks Shy Away Credit Unions Meet America’s Small Businesses’ Needs Member business lending continues to outpace other components in credit unions’ loan portfolio. As FDIC insured institutions continue to tighten their lending standards, credit unions are filling in the gap by providing more members with business loans.
Another Bank Falls, More Opportunities for Credit Unions According to Callahan & Associates analysis, a minimum of 15-20% of recently merged branch deposits find a new home during the year a merger or sale occurs. This suggests that between $1.8 and $2.4 billion from Guaranty Bank’s 162 branches will be “in play” over the coming year.
Biggest Bank Failure in 2009 (so far): $20 billion of Deposits on the Move According to Callahan & Associates research, a minimum of 15-20% of “sold” branch deposits find a new home during the year a merger or sale occurs. This suggests that between $3 to $4 billion dollars from the 346 branches will be looking for a new home due to the Colonial Bank failure.
First Look: Credit Unions on Record Lending Pace in 2009 According to data from Callahan & Associates' First Look program, credit unions are on pace for a record year of lending at a time when credit availability remains a key issue across the nation.
The Power of Data: Credit Union Deposit Market Share Growth Credit unions experienced significant share growth over the last 12 months. But how will this affect deposit market share?
Articles By Date
 
Most Popular Products
Peer to Peer

The most advanced financial performance software on the market-perfect for CFOs and CEOs who like to get their hands dirty with the numbers!

More Info>

CUAnalyzer

Designed for anyone in the industry, new or veteran, CUAnalyzer uses the powerful engine of our Peer-to-Peer software but provides educational tools to back up the graphing and reporting capabilities.

Login       More Info>

Credit Union Directory
For the first time in 22 years, the 2008 Credit Union Directory is now available in two versions, traditional and a new Briefcase Edition.
Login More Info>
CU Strategy & Performance (CUSP)

Credit Union Strategy and Performance (CUSP) is Callahan's new hybrid print/online quarterly financial analysis publication that will place our expertise in analysis and consulting right in the palm of your hands.

More Info>

Login More Info>
Advertising Advertising