Callahan Clients, please log in for direct access to:
Learn What You're Missing
Upgrade Your Subscription
Thank you for your interest in reading the fantastic content we have on CreditUnions.com! However, the page you are trying to access is for subscribers-only. To learn more, select an option below.
All users must now log in to read, research, browse, and have fun on CreditUnions.com. Yes, we still offer freebies. And, yes, it’s worth the extra effort.
Print or PDF this article today because you won't have access to it later. Or, click here to learn how to get 24/7 access.
Chances are you’ve read about remarketing repossessed collateral or lease-return vehicles via the Internet. Maybe you even considered it but didn’t because the Internet seemed too risky or cutting edge. Following are some facts about Internet remarketing, and three credit union case studies that demonstrate just how mainstream and productive Internet remarketing has become.
Millions of Vehicles Sold Each Year On the Internet
The president of eBay Motors reported in 2004 that his company facilitated the sale of more than one million vehicles from consumers, auto dealers, banks and credit unions. Automotive manufacturers are also using the Internet to remarket lease-returns. In 2002 General Motors launched GM SmartAuction, and recently celebrated one million vehicles sold. Even the nation’s two largest private auction wholesalers, Manheim and Adesa, have launched Internet-based auctions for remarketing vehicles direct to dealers. In fact, Manheim recently announced it was developing an Internet remarketing platform especially for the nation’s premier banks to sell repos and lease-returns directly to participating auto dealers anywhere in the nation.
Credit Unions Catching On
Fortunately for the movement, more credit unions are tapping into the Internet’s potential. Anecdotal evidence suggests more than 10% of credit unions are using Internet vehicle remarketing of some kind, including using eBay Motors or manually posting vehicles for sale on their website. Evidence also suggests that recaptured revenue can be substantial, including shortened remarketing cycles, higher sale prices and, in some cases, new loan revenue—often at equal or lower costs than traditional remarketing channels. Here are three examples of credit unions using the Internet for vehicle remarketing.
“I would hate to sell a convertible in Oregon [during winter], but someone in Florida might be interested in it,” says Jerry Liudahl, VP of Lending at Oregon Community Credit Union (OCCU) in Eugene, Oregon ($704 million). That’s why when OCCU repossesses a vehicle, it first decides whether the vehicle is marketable locally. If not, OCCU uses eBay Motors to sell the vehicle quickly, earning 105-120% of wholesale, rather than the 70-75% it might get at a traditional channel. “We use eBay for unique vehicles that don’t have a wide market in our area and won’t bring a reasonable price at [a traditional wholesale] auction,” says Liudahl. “Plus, you reach a much wider audience,” Liudahl says, explaining that selling to distant buyers is appropriate for OCCU, which with over 100% loan-to-share isn’t concerned with building its loan portfolio.
Do-it-yourself Remarketing Tools
Ent Federal Credit Union in Colorado Springs, Colorado ($1.7 Billion) took matters into its own hands in 2001 and developed a proprietary tool for conducting eBay-style auctions on its own website. Ent’s internal development team built the auction tool by adapting an off-the-shelf software package to its own needs. The auction page lets members view vehicle photos and descriptions, apply for loans, request test-drive appointments, place bids and even buy MBI coverage. In 2004, the program g enerated over $1 million in new auto loans, and earned higher resale prices than the credit union had received through traditional remarketing channels.
Since 2002, Northwest Community Credit Union in Springfield, Oregon ($450 million) has used remarketing tools from cuAuctions™ (www.titleauctions.com) to conduct eBay-style auctions for repossessed collateral on its website, and on www.cuAuctions.com. The credit union has not only enjoyed final sale prices 10-15% higher than traditional remarketing channels, it has boosted its loan portfolio, as well. “We’re financing about 50% of the vehicles we auction off,” says Dennis Powell. In addition, Powell reports member response to the auction is strong, generating 35,000 website hits per month, making the auction page the second most visited on the credit union’s website.
CUAuctions™, powered by TitleAuctions, delivers retail, wholesale and member vehicle remarketing tools, as well as training and support, exclusively designed for credit unions. Currently serving 57 credit unions nationwide, CUAuctions’ credit union clients enjoy average sale prices $2,100 per vehicle higher than traditional remarketing channels, as well as new loan revenue and increased Web site traffic. For more information, go to www.titleauctions.com, or contact president Mark Coleman at email@example.com.
May 9, 2005
7/26/2012 04:12 PM
this is the kind of article we need to find outside sourcing for repos that won't even sell for loan value
Very well done. Informative, concise with multiple examples.
Thank you for your comments, the TitleAuctions team has read each of them carefully. We'll be able to discuss Internet remarketing in more depth at the upcoming 7th Annual Auto Lending Symposium in Las Vegas, sponsored by CU Direct Corp (CUDL). If you'll be at the Symposium, please come to one of the remarketing breakout sessions offered on Thursday, June 23. TitleAuctions president, Mark Coleman, will be one of three panelists presenting ideas on how to optimize remarketing results.
The article was good. However it was to breif. This could be a very good revenue source for many credit unions. Is anybody smaller doing it? Could further extend the case studies
You don't provide the negatives of doing business in this manner. Where are the vehicles stored while waiting for them to sell? Does the credit union have to pay insurance on vehicles while waiting for a sell? Through private auctions, we don't have to file UCC Codes or pay taxes on sold vehicles, how would this method affect us?
Submit your email address to receive daily industry updates and web-only features.
P: (800) 446-7453 | F: (800) 878-4712
1001 Connecticut Ave. NW Suite 1001
Washington, DC 20036