The Argument For Doubling Down On Deposits

While banks drop free checking and debit reward programs, credit unions see checking accounts as the first stepping stone in building deeper member relationships.

 
 

As of third quarter 2011, credit union checking accounts grew at 3.6% annually, or five times the 0.7% growth rate of credit union membership. Why is this significant? Because checking accounts are viewed as a proxy for where a member holds their primary financial institution relationship, and many credit unions track checking (share drafts) accounts with direct deposit in their key organizational success measures. The growth of checking accounts indicates that more members are turning to credit unions for their day-to-day banking needs.

Checking Accounts Are Growing At 5 Times The Rate Of Membership
For all U.S. credit unions | Data as of 09.30.11
Callahan & Associates' 12-Month Checking Account Growth
Source: Callahan & Associates' Peer-to-Peer Software.

Today, more than 49% of members have a checking account and the growth is being shared across the industry. More than 70% of credit unions grew their checking accounts and 13% grew at double digits!

Gaining Steam

Some might attribute this activity to Bank Transfer Day, but check out the timeline. The data above is as of Sept. 30, well before Nov. 5. And the trends were moving in the right direction even before then. 

The FDIC releases deposit levels by branch each year as of June 30. When overlayed with credit union deposits, that data shows market share that can be analyzed down to the branch level. According to BranchAnalyzer, an online deposit market share tool from Callahan & Associates, deposit market share stands at 9.07%, having increased in 31 states between June 2010 and June 2011. The top 10 states in growth are listed below. Click on the map to see each state’s market share as of June 2011.

Top 10 States By Largest YOY Change In Deposit Market Share
Data as of 09.30.11
  YOY Change
In BPS
2011 2010
Vermont 104 18.20% 17.20%
South Carolina 80 11.00% 10.20%
Alabama 74 14.50% 13.80%
Washington 72 20.00% 19.30%
New Mexico 72 19.40% 18.70%
South Dakota 61 2.40% 1.80%
Michigan 60 18.50% 17.90%
Idaho 58 17.30% 16.70%
Iowa 52 10.40% 9.90%
West Virginia 52 8.00% 7.50%
Source: Callahan & Associates' Peer-to-Peer Software.
Deposit Market Share
For all U.S. credit unions | Data as of 06.30.11
Callahan & Associates' Deposit Market Share Map
Source: Callahan & Associates' Branch Analyzer | Click the map to view full size.

 

Why Are Deposits Important?

In today’s landsape, it’s difficult for financial institions to generate income. Interest income is tight and fee income opportunities are limited. Many banks (and some credit unions, too) are chasing off deposits because of interest expenses and servicing costs. So what’s the argument for pursuing deposits?

The answer is simple: Deposit accounts are the first stepping stone in building deeper member relationships. While banks are dropping free checking and debit reward programs, credit unions are doubling down on enticing deposit strategies. Here are some examples:

Senior Editor Rebecca Wessler provides more in-depth analysis of RBFCU’s program as well as an interview with SAFE Credit Union CEO Henry Wirz on his Perfect Cents program in the third quarter 2011 edition of Credit Union Strategy & Performance (CUSP), available soon.

Next Steps: Turning Deposits Into Loans

Helping credit unions leverage new deposit relationships into profitable full-service ones will be the focus of CreditUnions.com for the next few months. Starting in January, we are launching “theme weeks” which will provide a range of perspectives on challenges and opportunities facing credit union executives. January kicks off with Credit Card week on January 9. We’ll look at successful affinity relationships, how to measure card program profitability, the latest technological advances in cards, whether to offer rewards, and more. We’ll also have commentary and analysis from guest author and credit card expert Timothy Kolk of TRK Advisors. In February, we’ll tackle Mortage Lending and March brings Auto Week.

Stay tuned.